Paesano's Pizza

4.7 ( 243 reviews )
$10–20
35 N Main St, Jacobus, PA 17407, United States
+1 717-428-2831

If you find yourself in York County, Paesano's Pizza at 35 N Main St, Jacobus, PA, is a must-visit. Customers rave about this family-owned gem, often citing it as the best pizza in the area. Theresa Tomlinson enthusiastically describes it as "the best pizza in York," and highlights its wonderful homemade desserts, making it a well-rounded culinary experience.

Many reviewers emphasize the authenticity of the pizza, calling it "the real deal." Jeffrey Flegler lauds the establishment for achieving perfection in the four essential elements of pizza: crust, cheese, sauce, and consistency. The Sicilian family running the pizzeria brings a wealth of experience from previous establishments in Philly and Jersey, enriching every bite with tradition.

Even newcomers to the area, like Melissa Dunczyk from Chicago, have found their new favorite spot, praising the owners’ personable nature and delicious offerings. The passion for quality and customer satisfaction is evident, making Paesano's not just a place for pizza, but a community hub. If you appreciate good pizza, this establishment should be high on your list—it's a flavorful slice of Italian heritage worth savoring.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Comfort food
    • Quick bite
    • Small plates
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Dessert
    • Seating
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
    • Quiet
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs
    • Kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Parking

Reviews For Paesano's Pizza

Theresa Tomlinson
Jun 25,2025
Best pizza in York! Great family-owned business. Wonderful homemade desserts!
Dale McPherson
May 19,2025
My apology to the fine family that has been a staple of American culture with their excellent Italian recipes. Veronica who left a crappy review is your typical Karen!! Nothing is good enough for her. SHAME ON YOU VERONICA FOR YOUR CRAPPY REVIEW!! IT STINKS!!
Learn Film Repeat
May 15,2025
Fantastic place to get pizza. This is the real deal! Small family run pizza shop serving top of the line pizza.
Jeffrey Flegler
May 6,2025
Definitely the best pizza in all of York County. Seriously, there is absolutely nowhere else in the county that hits all four major pizza points like Paesano’s; crust, cheese, sauce, and consistency. The Sicilian family running the place had a shop in Philly and another in Jersey. Believe me, you’ll taste it.
Melissa Dunczyk
Apr 23,2025
Hands down the best pizza around. Coming from Chicago, I know about good pizza and it’s taken time to find but now we won’t order anywhere else. Owners are extremely nice and personable.
Kyle Kuzo
Apr 5,2025
Excellent pizza. We had lived in the area for several years and always forgot about this place when we craved pizza. After ordering today, we will absolutely be making this our new pizza place. It's hands down the best pizza we have tried in York County. The staff was also very friendly when we placed the order on the phone and at pickup.
brittany ruth
Mar 16,2025
Absolutely the best pizza in York county. I don't even eat pizza but if I get the family pizza on Fridays, I snag a piece of their pizza. They are always super nice and my order is always right. I've never had a bad experience there. Highly recommend trying if you haven't.
Kayla Marie
Mar 9,2025
Amazing family. They remember faces when you come in often enough. Treats everyone like family. They pour their love into their food which always comes out amazing. Andrew and Anna are the greatest around. Their service is phenomenal and they always rise above my expectation. There's always good vibes when me and my fiance walk in and we're always happy to see them. we practically consider them as family because they always help us out.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Fuh Vietnamese Restaurant
(394 review)
Fuh Vietnamese Restaurant
  • 994 Huron St Unit 5, London, ON N5Y 4K6, Canada
Vietnamese restaurant
+1 548-866-0096
The Drive In Restaurant
(2893 review)
The Drive In Restaurant
  • 572 Bench St, Taylors Falls, MN 55084, United States
Hamburger restaurant
+1 651-465-7831
La Oaxaqueña
(211 review)
La Oaxaqueña
  • 1460 S State St, South Salt Lake, UT 84115, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 801-484-6584
Noodles Express
(242 review)
Noodles Express
  • 15 Commonwealth Ave, Mount Pearl, NL A1N 1W4, Canada
Chinese restaurant
+1 709-368-6666
La Bocha Náutica
(215 review)
La Bocha Náutica
  • Hacienda el Tintero 370, Villas del Mesón, 76230 QUERETARO, Qro., Mexico
Restaurant
+52 442 241 3438
The Coffee Club
(105 review)
The Coffee Club
  • 60 George St, Bathgate EH48 1PD, United Kingdom
coffee shop
+44 1506 656352
Byblos Downtown
(3403 review)
Byblos Downtown
  • 11 Duncan St, Toronto, ON M5V 3M2, Canada
Middle Eastern restaurant
+1 647-660-0909
Toya Sushi
(176 review)
Toya Sushi
  • 1306 Mission St, Santa Cruz, CA 95060, United States
sushi restaurant
+1 831-464-1818
Horse in the Alley
(142 review)
Horse in the Alley
  • 1421 17th Pl, Bakersfield, CA 93301, United States
Restaurant
+1 661-843-7982
Sunrise Buffet
(536 review)
Sunrise Buffet
  • 2 Mascoma St #5, Lebanon, NH 03766, United States
Chinese restaurant
+1 603-448-9588